« It has begun | Main | 2008: Hopenchange; 2010: Doomngloom »

992 words about poverty, real and imagined

Posted on Thursday, March 18, 2010 at 04:54PM by Registered CommenterC. Brooks Kurtz Bookmark and Share

Note well the term “poor.” These are not Dickensian or Joads poor, but largely Americans who by the standards of the 1940s would be considered lucky. Partly because of globalized Chinese consumer goods, and partly redistributive practices of a half-century, our current “underclass” has access to clothes, electronics, entertainment, apartments, cell phones, transportation, etc., undreamed of by the middle class of the recent past. I live in one of the poorest areas of one of the poorest counties in a bankrupt state; and those I see poor are not like those I saw 40 years ago in the same locale.Victor David Hanson, Reflections on the Revolution in America

==

For my job, I spend a decent amount of time in McCurtain County, the most southeast of Oklahoma’s 77 counties. It has natural beauty that few other areas of Oklahoma offer. Beaver’s Bend, as a state park and resort, is gorgeous. It reminds me of Lake Eufala, which I think is the most beautiful areas of our state.

McCurtain County is also filled with tiny little villages, places like Watson, Smithville and Hayword. When many people think of the term “village,” they imagine quaint, rural places that pepper the state of Vermont, or they think of the Middle Ages.

When I go to these tiny towns, I’m dumbstruck by the grinding, self-defeating poverty that riddles them. This is not an elitist reflection of people I see beneath me; I don’t think that way. Rather, when I see groups of people large enough to have schools and infrastructure, I’m baffled that they live in school buses and fifth wheels, that their crackerbox houses are anchored on cement blocks and fronted with unstable porches. Driving through many of these towns, you’ll see more windows without glass than windows containing glass.

I was looking at the car of an old man in one such town, and what I assume was his grandson was with him. As I did my work, the little boy, 7 or 8 at the most, pulled out a pack of Red-Man tobacco and put a large chunk in his mouth. I didn’t say a word because, frankly, I don’t care, but it’s shocking to see a child chewing leaf tobacco in front of an adult (the only other shock I’ve had with tobacco was the girls at Colorado College, which at in the early 90s had a cost of $20,000/year, who dipped snuff – turns out it was a boarding school thing, since you couldn’t smoke there for fear of detection).

I remember my trip to Ireland and England over the change of the year  in 2002-03, and when we left Ireland and took the train from Gatwick Airport into London, passing the shanty row houses. They resembled what many American home-owners call a work house or a storage shed, yet these were the homes of people. Although America has its highlights of soul-grinding poverty – think Detroit – it’s hard to imagine such a life.

When I go to the smaller villages in southeastern Oklahoma, I don’t get it. Being poor is one thing, but having access to running water and electricity and still living in filth is quite another. I grew up in the country, and my parents still live in my childhood home. Our place is middle class, but improved upon over the years and beautiful. It has a well-manicured front lawn, a long driveway, multiple large trees, the American flag on a pole in the center of the front pasture. Our front yard once had no fence, then had a rail fence, now has a chain-link fence. It didn’t turn into what it is overnight – it’s taken 33 years of work to get it to look like what it does now.

Across the street from us lives a large, multi-generational family of what is known (and I hate this term) poor white trash. Their property has been drenched in squalor since they obtained it – how many trailers are on it I do not know (I live in a trailer – this in and of itself is not bad, nor is my observation snobbery), and it has among other features a lagoon, weeds taller than most people, and quite possibly a human cemetery.

One of the sons of my generation, the one who lives directly across from us, rejected that poverty, took his plot of the family land, and manicured it. The family is poor and it took some time, but like many people who grow up poor, he clearly learned the lesson that as an economic addition it’s difficult, but as a state of mind it is soul-draining.

I quoted Hanson because his notion of what American poor is so differs from what is popularly thought throughout the world. In the most destitute areas of Africa, the life expectancy is short for a variety of reasons, but in many villages the cause of natural death is burning dung – yes, shit – in their stoves for warmth and for cooking. This leads to a plethora of respiratory illnesses, and take it from there.

Many people still have parents and grandparents who grew up in the Great Depression, and they have their stories about saving pennies. What a waste in so much of America that we have people who have resources – again, running water, indoor plumbing, electricity – and even though they live in a shithouse, they have a cell phone and a satellite dish. That may sound like an absurd generalization, but take a trip to the poorest areas of your area, and notice how many people have made sure there’s enough money in the budget for 200 channels, but not nearly enough for a few hours of labor cleaning up their own place.

Seeing such poverty is depressing when you know there’s nothing the people can do about it. Seeing it when they have options is infuriating, especially when you can count on it that they live off some form of public assistance.

 

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (3)

Thanks for your observations. It's an issue that baffles, confuses, and occasionally saddens me. Some are in this situation through horrible life circumstance and, I think, legitimate beneficiaries of hopefully temporary aid. Welfare paid for my birth from my single mom (who never married) but she went on to work 30 years at Uniroyal and now has a decent pension while working part time at a retail store in Edmond. We lived the majority of our time in a trailer house on my great-grandmother's land but good lawzy gracious there would NEVER have been a run-down piece of our property if she had anything to say about it.

It's the kid part that I hate the most. They are indeed innocent and sponges soaking up what they see and hear and learn as 'normal.' Living off 'the man' is all some of them have ever known and become to presume that's the the best and perhaps only way to live.

Economically poor is one thing but poor in spirit is another...as I believe you have alluded to.

This whole interlude means little, I know, and has no point. I just liked your article and wanted to briefly share some of the thoughts it elicited for me.
March 19, 2010 | Unregistered Commentersgtboz
A couple of comments:

1) I am a big fan of McCurtain County and agree with what CBK observes. Recently though, McCurtain has experienced an infusion of wealth from a few sources: a) tourism and investment from wealthy weekenders from DFW. b) More transformatively, wealth from natural gas /energy leases. Many of the landowners (who by definition are relatively "wealthy" compared to others you mention) are cashing big checks. Yet to be seen if recent events serve to "pull up" those not benefiting...

b) Two resonses on poverty: 1) Perhaps some folks really don't grasp their poverty if it feels like the norm with there peers, classmates, neighbors, etc. 2) With apologies for the sweeping generalizations, it seems to me that poverty fundamentally can rob people (possessing modern improvements), of the pride that compels one to improve, beautify, etc.

c) Off-topic from the column: I'm lucky enough to know sgt. boz's family. His late Mamaw, whose influence I will never forget, proudly ran a daycare business/ranch that was a natural wonderland for any child fortunate enough to spend time there. She echoed and lived many of the same values taught to me by my family. To be raised with these values is one of the greatest gifts.
March 19, 2010 | Unregistered Commenterdwh
Thanks for the comments, guys. "The Redneck Manifesto's" first chapter deals with many of the angles mentioned by me, as well as both of your comments. One statement I've heard from many of my parents' generation concerns the 'as kids, we didn't even know we were poor.' I like sgtboz's notion of a 'poverty of spirit.' My piece was not meant as politics, but I do believe the longer people live on public assistance, the more likely a poverty of spirit is to become ingrained.
March 19, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterKing Kurtz

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.